Do carbon reduction targets work?

by Sam Roggeveen - 9 July 2008 9:40AM

Yesterday Warwick McKibbin argued some countries which have set greenhouse gas reduction targets are not meeting them. That debate — and the related question of whether the Kyoto protocol is working in Europe — is continued on Global Dashboard, with a defence of Kyoto. Make sure you read down to the comments section of the post, which includes a reply from Kyoto critic Ted Nordhaus.

The Global Dashboard post also contains some good links; for instance, the broader question of whether a top-down target-based approach to emissions reduction works is addressed in an op-ed in Nature magazine, published last year.

I'm finding my thinking on this issue evolving rapidly over the last few weeks, towards a greater scepticism of large-scale, long-term initiatives like carbon trading. As the Nature op-ed recommends, the more effective answer might be a massive investment in clean energy R&D, though you could argue that a carbon price would be a good way to pay for such investment.

UPDATE: What he said.

Comments

7/20/2008 2:10:07 PM #

pingback

Pingback from eastasiaforum.wordpress.com

Tiddlywinks on Climate Change « East Asia Forum

eastasiaforum.wordpress.com

8/18/2008 4:04:36 PM #

pingback

Pingback from eastasiaforum.org

Tiddlywinks on climate change « East Asia Forum

eastasiaforum.org

12/27/2008 11:23:42 AM #

pingback

Pingback from eastasiaforum.org

Tiddlywinks on climate change | East Asia Forum

eastasiaforum.org

Australia in the Asian Century

An Interpreter feature examining the themes of the Gillard Government’s ‘Australia in the Asian Century’ White Paper. Click here to see every post published in this series.

Email Digest  

To receive a weekly digest of ‘Australia in the Asian Century’ posts from The Interpreter via email, enter your email address:

Receive a weekly digest ->

Preview   |   Powered by FeedBlitz

Selected Interpreter posts also appear in:

 
Business Spectator Caing online The Diplomat
 

Keep up-to-date with The Interpreter through:

iPhone App   iPhone App

RSS Feed   The Interpreter RSS Feed

Email Digest  

To receive a digest of posts from The Interpreter via email, enter your email address:

Receive a daily digest ->
Receive a weekly digest ->

Preview   |   Powered by FeedBlitz

Interpreting the Aid Review

This is the archive of a Lowy Institute blog which ran from January to April of 2011. It was published to debate the Gillard Government's independent aid review, which was then in its research and consultation phase. We offer this archive as a service to researchers and the general public.